Semantic vs Lexical Similarity
Semantic similarity and lexical similarity are two distinct ways of comparing text, with the key difference being meaning versus surface-level features.
/ 3 min read
Table of Contents
AI Generated Podcast
Semantic Similarity vs. Lexical Similarity
Semantic similarity and lexical similarity are two distinct ways of comparing text, with the key difference being meaning versus surface-level features.
Here’s a detailed breakdown:
1. What is Lexical Similarity?
Lexical similarity measures how similar two pieces of text are based on their words, without considering their meanings. It focuses on surface-level features such as:
- Exact word matches
- Overlapping words
- Spelling or character similarity
Key Characteristics
- Focus: Compares the literal structure of the text.
- Doesn’t Consider Meaning: Two texts can be lexically similar but semantically different.
- Methods: Techniques like Jaccard similarity, cosine similarity on bag-of-words, or edit distance (Levenshtein distance).
Examples
- High Lexical Similarity
- Text 1: “The cat sat on the mat.”
- Text 2: “The cat sat on the mat.”
- These sentences are identical, so they have high lexical similarity.
- Low Lexical Similarity but High Semantic Similarity
- Text 1: “The cat sat on the mat.”
- Text 2: “A feline rested on a rug.”
- Lexically, these sentences share no overlapping words, so their lexical similarity is low. However, they mean the same thing.
- High Lexical Similarity but Low Semantic Similarity
- Text 1: “The dog chased the cat.”
- Text 2: “The cat chased the dog.”
- These sentences use the same words but convey different meanings.
2. What is Semantic Similarity?
Semantic similarity measures how similar two pieces of text are based on their meanings. It goes beyond word matching to understand context and relationships between words.
Key Characteristics
- Focus: Compares meaning rather than surface structure.
- Context-Aware: Accounts for synonyms, paraphrasing, and context.
- Methods: Techniques like word embeddings (e.g., Word2Vec, GloVe), contextual embeddings (e.g., BERT), and knowledge-based approaches (e.g., WordNet).
Examples
- High Semantic Similarity
- Text 1: “The cat sat on the mat.”
- Text 2: “A feline rested on a rug.”
- These sentences have different wording but convey a similar meaning.
- Low Semantic Similarity
- Text 1: “The dog barked loudly.”
- Text 2: “The sun is shining brightly.”
- These sentences have no meaningful relationship in terms of their content.
3. Key Differences Between Semantic and Lexical Similarity
| Feature | Lexical Similarity | Semantic Similarity |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Measures similarity based on exact words or characters. | Measures similarity based on meaning or context. |
| Focus | Surface-level comparison of text (literal). | Deeper understanding of meaning and relationships. |
| Handling Synonyms | Does not recognize synonyms (e.g., “happy” ≠ “joyful”). | Recognizes synonyms and paraphrases (e.g., “happy” ≈ “joyful”). |
| Context Awareness | Ignores context; treats words independently. | Considers the context in which words are used. |
| Techniques Used | Bag-of-Words, Jaccard index, edit distance. | Word embeddings (Word2Vec, BERT), cosine similarity of vectors. |
| Example Sentences | ”The cat sat” vs. “The cat sat” → High | ”The cat sat” vs. “A feline rested” → High |
4. Practical Applications
Lexical Similarity Applications
- Plagiarism Detection
- Identifies exact matches or slightly altered text by comparing word overlap.
- Spell Checking and Autocorrection
- Finds similar words based on character-level edits (e.g., “hte” → “the”).
- Keyword Matching in Search Engines
- Matches user queries with documents containing exact keywords.
Semantic Similarity Applications
- Search Engines (Semantic Search)
- Matches user queries with documents based on meaning rather than exact keywords.
- Example: A search for “What is AI?” retrieves articles about artificial intelligence even if they don’t use those exact words.
- Matches user queries with documents based on meaning rather than exact keywords.
- Chatbots and Virtual Assistants
- Understands user intent even if phrased differently.
- Example: “Tell me a joke” ≈ “Make me laugh.”
- Understands user intent even if phrased differently.
- Machine Translation
- Ensures that translations preserve meaning across languages.
- Text Summarization
- Identifies semantically important parts of a document to create summaries.
- Paraphrase Detection
- Determines whether two sentences mean the same thing despite different wording.
5. Real-Life Analogy
Think of lexical vs semantic similarity like comparing two books:
- Lexical similarity is like comparing books by their covers—if they look identical, they’re considered similar.
- Semantic similarity is like reading the books to see if their stories or ideas are alike, even if their covers are different.
Conclusion
While lexical similarity focuses on surface-level characteristics like word overlap or spelling, semantic similarity delves deeper into understanding meaning and context. Both play important roles in NLP tasks, but semantic similarity is more powerful for applications where understanding meaning is critical—like search engines, chatbots, and translation systems!